• Pizza at at Cosentino Pizzeria
  • Ice cream Sundae at Cosentino Pizzeria
  • Spaghetti and meatballs at Cosentino Pizzeria
  • Soft Serve Cones at Cosentino Pizzeria
  • Eggplant Parmigiano at Cosentino Pizzeria
  • Pizza at Cosentino Pizzeria
  • Chicken Wings at Cosentino Pizzeria
  • Meatball Sub at Cosentino Pizzeria

Call or stop by to place your lunch, dinner or catering order.

In A Rush? Try Our Fresh GRAB & GO

Prepared sandwiches, salads, sauces, pastries, and homemade fresh bread

Weekly Discounted Pizza Specials

Influenced by the Southern Italian tradition, and a love of good food, our philosophy is straightforward: to use the freshest, best quality ingredients, prepare our food simply and properly, and to serve it with joy. The stone oven is at the heart of our Pizzeria and what makes our handcrafted pizzas come alive with flavor, bringing inspiration to the rest of our menu. Whether you are choosing one of our favorites, or creating your own, we invite you to share in the experience of what makes Cosentino Pizzeria so special. Mangiamo!

For pick-up or catering, give us a call today at 330.850.5055 or email info@cosentinorestaurants.com.

Menu

Our authentic Italian cuisine is chef inspired with  family recipes made fresh from scratch daily

Pizza

Hand-tossed and baked in our stone oven Create Your Own Pizza!
Traditional Roasted Tomato Sauce (red) or Aglio Olio (white)
Small 911 (6 slices): 6.95
Medium 1211 (8 slices): 9.95
Large 1611 (12 slices): 12.95
Half Sheet: 15.95 | Full Sheet: 25.95
(Please allow for a 24 hour notice)
Classic Toppings: pepperoni, sausage, meatball, fresh mushrooms, tri-colored peppers, onions, banana peppers, plum tomatoes
sm: 1.00 | med: 1.50 | lg: 1.75 half: 3.00 | full: 3.75
Premium Toppings: fresh spinach, roasted eggplant, portabella mushrooms, kalamata olives, roasted peppers, chicken, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, goat cheese fresh basil
sm: 1.25 | med: 1.75 | lg: 2.00

Stromboli $7.95

Our house-made stromboli is stuffed with freshly sliced salami, pepperoni, prosciutto, mozzarella, pecorino, romano, roasted garlic, and fresh basil. Comes with a roasted tomato sauce side.

Calzone- Create Your Own $7.95

Roasted tomato sauce, mozzarella, provolone, pecorino
Classic Toppings ($1.00 each) | Premium Toppings ($1.00 each)

CHEF RECOMMENDE SPECIALTY PIZZA

Small: 9.95 | Medium: 13.95 | Large: 18.95
Spicy Margherita Pepperoni Crispy pepperoni, roasted tomato sauce, red pepper, melted mozzarella and pecorino
Bolognese Crumbled Italian sausage and meatball, tomato sauce, melted mozzarella and romano
Classic Caprese Aglio olio, roasted tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, balsamic drizzle
Chicken Parmagiano Crispy chicken, tomato, melted mozzarella
Prosciutto Spinach Aglio Olio EVOO, roasted garlic, goat cheese
Roasted Veggie Roasted eggplant, portabella, red peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil, balsamic glaze
Deluxe Pepperoni, sausage, tri-colored peppers, mushrooms, onions
Cauliflower Crust Margherita Medium Only Our gluten-free cust topped with roasted tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil

APPS & SIDES

Old World Style Italian Greens $5.95  Fresh escarole, roasted garlic, parmesan, EVOO, crostini
Mozzarella Fritti $6.95  Hand-breaded, fresh mozzarella served with roasted tomato sauce
Italian Sausage and Peppers $4.95  Served with tomato sauce and pecorino romano
House Meatballs $3.95  Served with tomato sauce and pecorino romano
Fresh Cut Parmesan Garlic French Fries $2.95 
Deluxe Garlic Bread $3.95  Toasted, fresh Italian bread, roasted garlic aglio o/io, melted mozzarella, and romano
Classic Buffalo Wings $6.95 (6) | $10.95 (12) Crispy, tossed, served with celery
and house blue dressing
Italian-Style Wings 6.95 (6) | 10.95 (12) Roasted garlic aioli, parsley, parmesan

SALADS

lnsalata Giardino (House) $ 3.95 A lovely combination of mixed greens and fresh vegetables, shredded mozzarella and romano, House Italian vinaigrette
Giardino Chickina $6.95 Our signature House Salad topped with crispy chicken
Antipasto $7 .95 Mixed greens tossed with salami, pepperoni, olives, onion, mozzarella, romano, and house dressing
Nonno’s Garden Tomato Salad (seasonal) $6.95 Garden plum tomato, fresh mozzarella,
pickled red onions, basil leaves
Walnut Crispy Chicken $7 .95 Mixed greens, candied walnuts, seasonal fruit, goat cheese, house vinaigrette, and balsamic drizzle

STONE OVEN ROASTED SUBS

Served on house-made Italian rolls (fresh-cut fries or simply tossed greens 1.95)
Classic Italian $6.95 Freshly-sliced salami, pepperoni, prosciutto, roasted red peppers, melted provolone, fresh greens, vinaigrette
Sweet or Spicy Italian Sausage and Peppers $6.95 Tri-colored peppers, caramelized onion, tomato sauce, melted mozzarella and romano
House-Made Meatball $6.95  Roasted meatballs, tomato sauce, melted provalone and romano
Hand-Breaded Chicken Parmagiano $7 .95 Toasted with tomato sauce, and melted provolone and romano
Chicken Cutlet $7.95  Crispy chicken, fresh lemon, greens, and tomato slices
Eggplant Parmagiano $6.95  Sliced garden eggplant, lightly breaded, and served parmagiano-style
Roasted Portabella $7 .95 Roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil, and balsamic drizzle

CHEF SPECIALTIES

Served with Pasta Cosentino
Hand-Breaded Chicken Parmagiano $8.95
Eggplant Parmagiano $8.95  Fresh eggplant, lightly coated in our house breadcrumbs
Chicken Romano Florentine $8.95 Crispy chicken cutlet topped with spinach aglio olio

PASTA AND HOUSE SPECIALTIES

Old World Spaghetti Cosentino $6.95 Slow-cooked with the freshest tomatoes, olive oil, spices, fresh meatballs, and sausage. The meat is removed to create our famous smooth sauce Served with fresh meatballs or Italian sausage ($2.50)
Our Famous Penne Pepperoni $7.95  Sauteed, crispy pepperoni, Cosentino sauce, baked with shredded mozzarella and pecorino
Penne Bolognese $7.95 Chopped meatball and sausage, Cosentino sauce, baked with shredded mozzarella and pecorino
Penne Tomato Cream $7.95 Roasted tomato cream, basil, romano
Spaghetti Al Fresco $6.95 EVOO, roasted garlic, chopped tomato, baby spinach, basil, pecorino
Spaghettini Aglio Olio $7.95 With Italian sausage and peppers
Fresh homemade lasagna available upon request

BEVERAGES

Coke Products and More!
2 Liter Bottles $2.95
20oz Bottles $1.90
8.5oz Coke Aluminum $1.79
Dunkin Donuts Cold Coffee $2.79
Monster Energy Drinks $2.99
Sports Drinks/ Powerade $1.79
Kids’ Juices $1.29
Dasani Water $1.79
Smart Water $1.99
Glaceau Vitamin Water $1.79
Gold Peak Tea (sweetened, unsweetened, green) $1.79
Orange Juice $2.29
Apple Juice $1.79

TINO’S PREMIUM ICE CREAM

We are proud to announce that we are offering premium ice cream! Try our delicious vanilla, chocolate, and swirl flavors in cake and waffle cones, and homemade milkshakes. Our sundaes are made with an edible chocolate waffle cup that will fulfill any ice cream dream. Enjoy our Ghiacciata, which is whipped to perfection and served in a cup for easy-eating our vast selection fulfill your ice cream cravings…until next time.
Cono Gelato Ice Cream $1.29 (sm/kld)*  Chocolate, vanilla, or swirl *add sprinkle’s and candy face $1.59
Cono Di Cialda (waffle cone) $1.79 (sm) | $2.79 (med) | $3,29 (lg) Chocolate, vanilla, or swirl
Frullati (milkshakes – 16oz) $3.69 Chocolate, vanilfa, or swirl
Ghiacciata (whipped sundae in a cup-16oz) $3.89 Peanut Butter or Reese’s Pieces

Cialdi Coppe (waffle sundaes) 4.29

Banana Extravaganza Vanilla ice cream topped with strawberry topping, pineapple, nuts, and a banana. To complete – whipped cream
PB Dream Vanilla ice cream topped with chunks of chocolate and peanut butter, covered with chocolate, and topped with whipped cream
Fudge Delight Vanilla ice cream covered in fudge, topped with peanuts and whipped cream
Brownie Diletta Swirl soft-serve ice cream covered in fudge with brownie bites and whipped cream
Chocolate Chip Biscotti Vanilla ice cream covered in fudge, chocolate chip cookie pieces, and topped with whipped cream

TINO’S PREMIUM COFFEES

A little of Italy from the Cup to Go section. Premium fresh-ground Italian espresso beans, along with a variety of lattes and cappuccinos will provide a rush of energy to start your day off right.
Fresh Ground Italian Coffee Italy’s Finest Premium Espresso Lattes $1.49 (med) | $1.89 (lg)
Espresso and chocolate, mocha, and caramel mocha
Cappuccinos $3.19 French vanilla, and mocha
Italian Pastries It is our pleasure to present quality Italian pastries that are homemade fresh daily with the finest ingredients. Each day will present a new pastry to compliment our premium espresso coffees to go.

CATERING

Please allow for a minimum 48 hours notice

Cosentino Signature Catering Package:
Chicken Romano, Pasta Cosentino, Garden Salad, Rolls …… $8.95/person (10 person minimum)

CATERING MENU

Half Pan (feeds 8-10)

  • Sausage and Peppers $29.95
  • Wings: Buffalo, or Italian (Half: 24 (Full: 48) $21.95
  • Fresh Roasted Garlic Bread $14.95
  • Pasta Cosentino $19.95
  • Pasta Cosentino (with Meatballs or Sausage) $24.95
  • Baked Pasta Bolognese $24.95
  • Pasta al Fresco $24.95
  • lnsalata Giardino (Garden Salad) $19.95
  • add chicken $24.95
  • Antipasto Salad $24.95
  • Walnut and Seasonal Fruit Salad $24.95
  • add chicken $24.95
  • Chilled Pasta Primavera Salad $24.95
  • Our Famous Chicken Romano Cutlets $39.95
  • Homemade Lasagna di Carne $24.95

Full Pan (feeds 15-20)

  • Sausage and Peppers $58.95
  • Wings: Buffalo, or Italian (Half: 24 (Full: 48) $43.95
  • Fresh Roasted Garlic Bread $29.95
  • Pasta Cosentino $39.95
  • Pasta Cosentino (with Meatballs or Sausage) $49.95
  • Baked Pasta Bolognese $49.95
  • Pasta al Fresco $49.95
  • lnsalata Giardino (Garden Salad) $39.95
  • add chicken $49.95
  • Antipasto Salad $49.95
  • Walnut and Seasonal Fruit Salad $49.95
  • add chicken $57.95
  • Chilled Pasta Primavera Salad $49.95
  • Our Famous Chicken Romano Cutlets $79.95
  • Homemade Lasagna di Carne $49.95

Ask about our assorted Italian pastries (market price)

Classic Italian Panini Tray $39.95/tray
Includes 20 pieces of Italian sub on our freshly baked Italian rolls

Pizza (Half & Full Sheet)
(See Pizza Menu)

Nonna’s Homestyle Sicilian Pizza 15.95/half
Thick crust, fresh tomato sauce, pecorino, romano, and basil

DESSERTS

Homemade Pizzelle Tray $24.95

Fresh Cannoli Tray $29.95

In A Rush? Try Our Fresh GRAB & GO

Prepared sandwiches, salads, sauces, pastries, and homemade fresh bread

Weekly Discounted Pizza Specials